The “Good” South Asian Child and Becoming Your Own Person

Photo by Jason Sung on Unsplash
You know that feeling when you find yourself agreeing to something that you really don’t want to do? Or, when someone says something you really don’t like but you convince yourself that it’s not worth it to bring it up?
You tell yourself that you’re being too sensitive, that you’re not really that busy, or that you can sleep next weekend. It’s just so much easier to not stir the pot and to let it go. Being the person who makes things feel awkward or uncomfortable is worse than a little exhaustion.
It feels good to be the understanding and considerate one that everyone can count on. But this also often comes at a cost to you. You become so focused on everyone else that you get lost in the mix. This leads you to feel exhausted, overworked, and so burnt out that you want to run away.
You can probably guess where this is going … You need boundaries. More self-care and assertiveness. Learn to say “no”.
Seems so easy, right?
Except, it’s not easy at all.
Knowing what you need and actually being able to get those needs met are two completely different things. This can feel particularly challenging when you grew up in a South Asian household, where being accommodating, putting others first, and minimizing yourself were instilled as values of a “good” person.
Sometimes saying “no” isn’t just about turning down plans or refusing another responsibility. It can bring up some really intense questions about who you are – are you selfish? disrespectful? ungrateful?
Can you still be a good person if you don’t adhere to the role that is expected of you?
Defining the “Good” South Asian child
Your understanding of what qualities make a good person don’t just come from nowhere. A lot of these thoughts, beliefs, and narratives develop in the environment in which you grow up, the relationships you have, and the interactions you see between others.
As a South Asian, you likely grew up in a household where respecting your elders, prioritizing your family, and being successful are considered the most important values. There is a strong emphasis on being mindful of others, over-extending yourself for your family, and making decisions that would make the most people happy (yourself not necessarily included).
For many South Asians and children of immigrants, these expectations carry an additional weight. Growing up in an immigrant household, you are often reminded of the sacrifices that your parents made to be where they are today. In turn, those sacrifices have led to the opportunities that you’ve been afforded that they couldn’t have had.
There is an unspoken and heavily felt understanding of the importance of making the most of these opportunities. You should work harder, do more, and, above all else, make your family proud.
Now, these are not bad things. It is not bad to be compassionate, considerate, or helpful. These values can be a core part of your being and an important way in which you maintain connection to your family.
However, there is a difference between these traits being a part of your values and only feeling valued for having these traits. When this line gets blurred you might struggle with the distinction between what your values are and what you’ve learned that a good daughter, son, or child is supposed to do.
Internalized “Goodness” in Adulthood
If you’re reading this, you’ve probably been told countless times how wonderful it is that you were such an easy child.
Now, in adulthood, you’re still “easy” – you don’t require too much attention, you figure things out, take care of others, and somehow makes everything work. And this makes you feel good about yourself. It’s a special talent to take care of and make everyone in your life feel seen and special.
This certainly shows up in your relationships. You’re probably very skilled in anticipating other’s needs, changing your behavior to avoid conflict, or putting aside your own feelings to keep everyone else comfortable.
When you were younger, you had to make yourself smaller and agreeable. This is what kept you safe, kept your parents from fighting, and just generally kept the trains moving on time. Being easy and accommodating was a way to receive love, care, and connection.
The concept of making yourself smaller and more agreeable feelings innate – but, it is also something that you have learned from your parents. Think about all the times where you heard your parents wanting to turn down an invitation to a social event and, then, ten minutes later rushing to get themselves ready and finding a gift to bring with them. Though this may seem small, it laid the foundation for the idea that you should put aside your own wants and preferences to avoid disappointing others. These patterns and expectations have been passed down through generations and not always consciously.
As an adult, though, this can keep you feeling stuck and unfulfilled. You might know how to figure out what everyone else needs, but, when someone asks you what you need, it’s a genuine struggle to come up with an answer.
Embracing “Badness”
When so much of your life has been built around being responsible, accommodating, and making others happy, doing something different can feel profoundly uncomfortable. Saying “no” makes you believe that you’re ungrateful. Disagreeing with your elders or parents feels disrespectful. Making a decision for yourself that doesn’t align with what your family expects is selfish.
You’re probably thinking “I know these things don’t make me ungrateful, disrespectful, or selfish” but that doesn’t mean that the guilt doesn’t exist. Just because you feel uncomfortable and guilty doesn’t mean that you’re doing something bad – just that you’re doing something that is unfamiliar to you.
Part of embracing your “badness” involves learning how to push through this discomfort and unfamiliarity. You also have to find a way to accept that you won’t always be perceived as agreeable and understanding. People will be disappointed in you or frustrated with your choices or think you’re trying to be difficult.
That is OKAY!
You do not always have to find a way to make your decisions comfortable for everyone else. This is a scary thought; but, also important in helping you define who you want to be.
Becoming Your Own Person
Part of this process is beginning to release the idea of being a good versus bad person. Consider, instead, what makes you a person that you’re proud of and confident in. Embrace yourself as a full human being rather than a binary judgment.
What do you value? What kind of relationship do you want to have? What makes you feel happy and fulfilled? These are just a few questions that, currently, may feel impossible to answer without your parents’ voice and family’s expectations in the back of your head. They are questions that are important for you to answer in your own voice to live a life that you recognize as your own.
Now, this doesn’t mean that you have to abandon the values that you grew up with or distance yourself from your culture. You can love your parents, hold your familys’ opinions dear, and respect your cultural beliefs while also making room for your own needs, wants, and beliefs.
Part of this journey is also learning to tolerate being imperfect. Learning that just because you made a decision that disappointed others, does not mean that you are not kind or caring. You can be a considerate person and take care of your needs and be assertive. The two are not mutually exclusive. As an idea, this can feel impossible and scary; but, once you are able to accept that people are imperfect, it can be so freeing and fulfilling.
The goal is not to become a person who does not care about others. It’s to become a person who cares about you just as much as you care about others.
Leave A Comment